Answers

Why make something that can be generated in seconds?

The visual is too loaded to be of any use.

From Laurel Schwulst, My Website Is a Shifting House, 2018

In May 2024 Google started answering searches itself, with an AI Overview on top of the results. Asked how to keep cheese from sliding off a pizza, it suggested adding glue to the sauce. The advice came from a joke posted on Reddit in 2012. Google's answer was a joke by itself, but lost what made it a joke in the first place: meaning and context.

No source to doubt

We used to search and get a list of results. Now we prompt and get one answer. Umberto Eco, in The Infinity of Lists (2009), treats the list as a way of knowing that never pretends to be complete. A page of results shows that something was chosen, and that there is more. An answer looks finished.

Without images

Even images now start from words. With image generators, Vinzenz Aubry notes in "In Defense of No Image" (2024), the relation flips: the prompt, the description, points to the image, not the other way round. His title answers Hito Steyerl's "In Defense of the Poor Image" (2009), about compressed copies that travel faster than any original. For Aubry, an image by itself doesn't represent anything. A photograph pointed to something that stood in front of the camera. A generated image points nowhere; a sentence points to it.
This is the death of representation. If an image takes a second, the question is no longer how to make it, but why.

Alt Text as Poetry

Someone who looked

When anything can be generated, what's left to make is a position: who, where, why. A page written in plain HTML shows it. As HTML Energy reminds us, anyone who wants to publish on the web can write HTML, and what you write by hand you can read, change and keep. Alt text is what a screen reader speaks in place of an image, and Alt Text as Poetry treats it as writing, not as a chore: words chosen by someone who looked.


In short: A generated answer drops its sources, a generated image points to nothing.
Reading: Vinzenz Aubry, "In Defense of No Image", 2024